Dear Bodhi Tree,
Thank you for sharing your amazing journey with us! Well said, and beautifully written. I hope that your website will be of great benefit to those seeking a truly effective, inspiring and practical way to address their addiction which, as you have pointed out, is misdirected bhakti.
While AA has helped many people, it has turned others off with its sense of "all or nothing, one drink and you are totally screwed, you are completely helpless/flawed and you will be an addict the rest of your life." My husband attended briefly and he said the meetings were depressing and made him want to drink more. In fact, he would drink on the way home! They told him, "Come back when you are tired of drinking," to which he replied, "If I were tired of drinking, I wouldn't need to come here, I would just stop!" (This has been substantiated by some research indicating that
most addicts eventually quit on their own when they are good and ready to quit.) I agree with your observations about AA, and that what is missing is a spiritual practice like AYP to fulfill the unmet needs of bhakti.
RE: psychedelics, I think you hit the nail on the head when you said, "the path is not so much about clinging to peak experiences as it is improving our moment-to-moment quality of life and inner well-being." My own experience with entheogens in my youth, always used sacramentally, carefully and with spiritual focus, was overwhelmingly positive and resulted in giving my spiritual life a huge jump-start, particularly the experiential reality of God! As Ram Dass has said, something to the effect, "Drugs can help you visit the mountaintop, but only a spiritual practice will allow you to live there." Thus I devoted myself with great enthusiasm to a serious lifelong daily yoga practice, to immerse myself in that Being/Consciousness/Bliss. At 51 my spiritual practice continues to bear much fruit.
A big caveat, however: Although the psychedelic experiences absolutely empowered and deepened my spiritual life, they also convinced me that worldly things, including money, career and social status were unimportant, and that the purpose of life is enlightenment [which of course, is true]. So, while drugs had been largely replaced by my spiritual practice (kriya yoga), I spent an excessive amount of time every day in meditation, at least an hour in the morning, half an hour at lunch and another hour or two at night. I made no real effort to pursue a serious career, and viewed my boring clerical job as a necessary evil in order to pay the rent so that I could spend time in meditation. I believed the New Age idea that if you are spiritual and try to be a good person and follow your dharma, then the universe will make money fall into your lap so you won't have to waste any energy on "materialistic" pursuits. I only got over this misconception fairly recently thanks to spending many, many years in the School of Hard Knocks.
Anyway, the point being, while there is no question that my youthful experimentation with entheogens advanced my spiritual life [for which I am eternally grateful!], it may have worked TOO WELL, by contributing to an "unworldliness" which has resulted in undesireable material consequences now that I am old and approaching retirement. I do sometimes wonder whether this is the reason that the classical Indian tradition recommends going off to seriously seek enlightenment AFTER you've worked, established your home, raised your kids, paid off your bills, etc.
In my youth I was actively seeking the High, whereas nowadays my task is to maintain a degree of "normalcy" and groundedness so as to "do what needs to be done," while walking and driving around with Love pouring through this body made of colored light whose boundaries are rather fluid... I literally wouldn't trade it for the world, but my life could have been much easier from the practical standpoint, had my path been more balanced and less excessive. That is one of the things I appreciate about AYP (as well as HOY), their emphasis on self-pacing and spiritual practices as an integrated part of a balanced lifestyle.
In any case, thanks again for all your good work, Bodhi, and I believe that people will benefit from your website!